Applying a risk-benefit analysis to outcomes in tuberculosis clinical trials

Citation: Miyahara S, Ramchandani R, Montepiedra G, Kim S, Gupta A, Swindells S, Chaisson R. Applying risk benefit analysis to outcomes from TB clinical trials. Clin Infect Dis. 2020 Feb 3;70(4):698-703. doi: 10.1093/cid/ciz784. PMID: 31414121.

Access full article:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31414121

Summary
Although it is common to analyze efficacy and safety separately in clinical trials, this could yield a misleading study conclusion if an increase in efficacy is accompanied by a decrease in safety. A risk-benefit analysis is a systematic approach to examine safety and efficacy jointly. Both the "rank-based" and "partial-credit" methods described in this paper allow researchers to create a single, composite outcome incorporating efficacy, safety, and other factors. The first approach compares the distribution of rankings between arms. In the second approach, a score can be assigned to each outcome category, considering its severity and comparing the mean or median scores of arms. The methods were applied to the A5279/Brief Rifapentine-Isoniazid Efficacy for TB Prevention study, and design considerations for future clinical trials are discussed, including the challenge of arriving at a consensus on rankings/scorings. If well designed, a risk-benefit analysis may allow for a superiority comparison and, therefore, avoid setting a noninferiority margin.

Categories

CRS
Topics

Clinical Trials

A5302:  BioBank for Surrogate Marker Research for TB...

Primary Objective To obtain sputum, serum, urine, and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) for central TB biorepository...

Read More

A5279, Phase III Clinical Trial of Ultra-Short-Course...

This study will enroll HIV-infected people who do not have evidence of active TB but who are at high risk of developing active...

Read More

NWCS 408: Examining Longitudinal Cytokine Profiles in HIV-TB...

Using existing data from A5274 and data obtained from retrospectively testing available biospecimens, we propose the following...

Read More

A5327: Sofosbuvir + Ribavirin w/o Interferon for Treatment...

A5327 SWIFT-C is a Phase I, open-label, two-cohort clinical trial, in which between 44 and 50 acutely HCV-infected HIV-1...

Read More

P1060:  Phase II, parallel, randomized, clinical trials...

A single dose of nevirapine (SD NVP) given to an HIV infected pregnant woman followed by a single dose to her infant has been...

Read More