The interaction between equipoise and logistics in clinical trials: A case study

Citation: Warshaw MG, Carey VJ, McFarland EJ, Dawson L, Abrams E, Melvin A, Fairlie L, Spiegel H, Jay J, Agwu AL; IMPAACT P1094 Team. The interaction between equipoise and logistics in clinical trials: A case study. Clin Trials. 2017 Jun;14(3):314-318. doi: 10.1177/1740774517690734. Epub 2017 Jan 31. PMID: 28135804; PMCID: PMC5446272

Access full article:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28135804

INTRODUCTION:
Equipoise is usually discussed as an ethical issue in clinical trials. However, it also has practical implications.

BACKGROUND:
Clinical equipoise is usually construed to mean uncertainty or disagreement among the expert clinician community. However, an individual physician's sense of equipoise may vary by location, based on the local standard of care or availability of specific treatment options, and these differences can affect providers' willingness to enroll participants into clinical trials. There are also logistical barriers to enrollment in international trials due to prolonged timelines for approvals by government agencies and ethical review boards.

CASE STUDY:
A multinational clinical trial of bridging strategies for treatment of non-adherent HIV-infected youth, experienced differing perceptions of equipoise due to disparities in availability of treatment options by country. Unfortunately, the countries with most demand for the trial were those where the approval process was most delayed, and the study was closed early due to slow accrual.

DISCUSSION:
When planning multicenter clinical trials, it is important to take into account heterogeneity among research sites and try to anticipate differences in equipoise and logistical factors between sites, in order to plan to address these issues at the design stage.

Categories

CRS
Topics

Clinical Trials

Impact of Tuberculosis Infection on HIV-1 Antibody Response...

Study Objective: Compare longitudinal HIV-1 antibody responses among HIV-1 infected participants that either did or did not...

Read More

P1073: Study of Immune Reconstitution Inflammatory Syndrome...

P1073 is a case controlled prospective, clinical, observational and pathogenesis study of HIV-infected infants and children...

Read More

NWCS 414, Evaluation of a Serum Biosignature for Identifying...

We will address our hypothesis using a case-control study design. We plan to leverage the existing biorepository of...

Read More

A5253: Sensitivity and Specificity of Mycobacterium...

An estimated 3 million HIV-infected individuals will enter programs for antiretroviral (ARV) treatment in the coming year, with...

Read More

A5349: Rifapentine-containing treatment shortening regimens...

The purpose of this study is to determine whether one or two four-month regimens of tuberculosis treatment are as effective as a...

Read More